Decoy Effect
The decoy effect changes what feels like a good choice by placing an intentionally inferior option beside the seller’s target. The decoy is designed not to win, but to make one comparison—and therefore one purchase—feel settled.
The Wall Street Journal once offered web access for $59, print for $125, or web plus print for the same $125. The print-only subscription looked absurd because it was: its job was to make the bundle feel irresistible.
E1The option that sells another option
You rarely judge an offer in isolation; you judge it against whatever sits beside it. A seller can exploit that by placing a visibly worse alternative near the preferred choice. Here, print-only and web-plus-print cost exactly the same, so the bundle dominates the decoy and acquires the glow of an obvious bargain. But that comparison answers only “Which $125 offer is better?” It quietly displaces the more important questions: “Do I want print at all?” and “Is either option worth $125?” The decoy narrows the decision until choosing the target feels less like spending and more like avoiding a mistake.
E1Where it shows up
The $125 subscription
The print-only tier was not a serious competitor. By surrendering the comparison so completely, it made the equally priced bundle appear to deliver free additional value.
E1Dominance is not value
A decoy can establish that one listed option is better than another; it cannot establish that the winning option meets your needs or is worth its price. If you already evaluate each offer against a fixed budget and purpose, the engineered comparison loses much of its force.
E1Delete the loser before deciding
When one tier looks laughably inferior, remove it from the menu mentally. Then compare the apparent winner with buying nothing: would you still pay $125 for the bundle if the print-only option had never appeared?
E1Episodes that teach this
-
The Dirty Tricks Behind Amazon & Flipkart Sales - Future IQ
· explained at 2:55
61,201 views
Wall Street Journal: web-only $59, print-only $125, web+print $125 — "The middle one, print only subscription was a decoy put there just to make you think that the third one is like an excellent deal."